Provocative commentaries on international issues, social development, and people and places by a veteran journalist
Why are Third Worlders so enamored of New York and Washington?
Published on January 14, 2005 By Pranay Gupte In Current Events
Having been a columnist for Newsweek International for 18 years, I would suggest this to fellow G2K list members: Don't take the magazine's selection of "leaders to watch" too seriously.

The choices are made quite arbitarily and, I submit, often without genuine in-depth knowledge of various regions. To name only one person -- Mohsen Kadivar -- in a region of more than 300 million people is actually quite capricious. Surely there are other men and women who might qualify for the moniker of "leaders to watch."

Newsweek selection raises a larger question of the influence that Western -- and specifically US -- media organization wield around the world. If, say, the Times of India, or the Gulf News (of Dubai) comes up with a list of "leaders to watch," it's unlikely that the selections would be taken very seriously around the world. It just so happens that the Times of India has a daily circulation of more than two million. newsweek International's circulation is barely 200,000, and that, I think, is charitably put.

Still, here we are, quoting Newsweek International. Isn't it time that the developing world shrugged off the hegemony of Western media? Of is it that we of Third World origin are too enamored of being "noticed" by media mandarins in New York and Washington?

Comments
on Jan 14, 2005
Tremendous blog, Pranay. I must admit that sometimes I wonder why I bother visiting JoeUser, given the frequency with which many of its contributors tend to shy away from original thought in favour of beating exceedingly tired old left-right political drums. (There, that'll earn me popularity!) But then something like your post comes along.

In response to your point, and at risk of lighting the blue touchpaper here, dare I suggest that some in the West - including many of those in positions of huge influence - may, despite vociferous claims to the contrary, secretly cling to the old colonial attitude of 'Life's cheap over there'. To me, what turns this from a mere outrage into something altogether sadder is that this attitude is not unknown in the developing world either. Until this throwback attitude is addressed in both regions, I see little chance of the overthrow of Western hegemony re. the media - or anything else.

And Newsweek International is doubtless nowhere near as truly international as it would like to think it was.

No doubt you will receive many responses along the lines of 'We are America and everybody else wants to be us', but I suspect that's not nearly as true as some Americans would like to believe.
on Jan 14, 2005
I totally agree.